Friday, November 20, 2026

An Astonishing Success!

Congratulations to SpaceX for an astonishingly successful Flight 15 “Starship/Superheavy” developmental test flight!

As near as I can tell from the videos off the SpaceX website,  plus the private cameras on the beach,  the upper stage flight was essentially perfect,  while the booster flight was a partial success,  with a perfect ascent,  but a flawed fly-back. 

I heard enough from the SpaceX video team while the ship was in orbit to understand that these stages flew completely autonomously,  right down to the detection of faults,  commanding abort trajectories,  and commanding flight termination destruction.

Booster ascent,  hot staging,  and second stage ascent all looked great.  It deployed all its “Starlink” satellites,  and ground contact was made with all of them.  Re-entry looked good,  the post-entry maneuvering descent not to overfly populations looked good,  and the ship successfully made its landing burn,  whereupon it was caught by the tower!  It all looked great!  An absolutely stunning achievement!

One booster engine in the outer ring of 20 fixed-mounted engines failed to light up for the boost-back burn,  but the remaining 32 engines did the job anyway.  None of the failures happened among the 13 inner gimballed engines (a ring of 10 and 3 in the center).   The planned sequence of 13,  then 5,  and then 3 gimballed engines for the final thrust-vectoring descent burn,  worked just fine. 

The SpaceX video team said something about the booster catch attempt being aborted,  before that final descent,  which took place to its end just off the beach.  Lots of people took cell phone videos of this,  and many have been posted on-line.  The Superheavy booster hovered about a stage length off the water,  shut down the last engines,  and then exploded starting from its forward end,  moving aft.  At that time,  the SpaceX video team had no reasons to give,  for this abort.

It was later,  during the ship descent and landing,  that I heard the SpaceX video team say that the booster had detected a problem or two,  and autonomously commanded an abort,  ending in that flight termination system destruction just above the water.  They did not say what those problems it detected were.  Maybe we will find out in the coming days.

If they can figure out what went wrong with the one engine during boost-back,  and whatever it was about the booster that went wrong in the fly-back that triggered the abort,  then the next development test flight should look all-around perfect.  And at that point they might be able to move into the final demonstration flight testing,  where they can demonstrate both the larger payloads long-claimed,  and the reliability needed to support eventual man-rating. 

A few of those final demonstration test flights without problems,  and the vehicle might be considered reliable enough to consider for fully operational unmanned use,  at which point they can start the development flight tests on the “Starship HLS variant” for one of NASA's two Artemis moon landers.  That one will have to be reliable enough to man-rate,  and rather quickly!

-----  

Search code DDMMYYYY format:  20112026

Search keywords:  forensics,  launch, space program

-----  

Update 11-16-2026:  I have come into possession of some information that the booster may have been running too low on propellant to risk the tower by hovering long enough to make the catch,  which triggered the automatic divert and subsequent descent to self destruction,  just above the water close to the beach where the tower is located. 

Supposedly it was running out of methane fuel first.  This speculation is supported by the lack of methane fireballs seen at engine shutdown,  and the green flash seen as its last engine shut down,  just as the self-destruct system fired.  That green is copper engine components burning with excess oxygen in contact with the metal.  This phenomena has been seen before.

-----  

Update 11-20-2026:  A version of this posting without the updates ran as a board-of-contributors column in the Thursday 11-19-2026 Waco “Tribune-Herald” newspaper.

-----   

1 comment:

  1. The reason for the divert might have been the low fuel in the main tanks shutting down boost back early. Leaving it a bit short on trajectory for safe tower catch.

    Landing burn uses fuel from separate tanks. Green flame could have been simply due to running engines till dry in hover. Iimiting the subsequent explosion.

    ReplyDelete