Wednesday, June 1, 2022

About Hypersonic Vehicles

added 8-16-2025:  search code 01062022,  search keywords ramjet, aerothermo, airplanes

------   

For hypersonic flight vehicles of any kind there are two fundamental problems that require solutions:  aeroheating and propulsion.  Of these,  the aeroheating is the more important!  If the design concept does not have a thermal management solution for the extreme aeroheating,  then regardless of any propulsion,  the design concept has no credibility at all!  See References 1 and 2 for more information.

The simplest propulsion solution is rocket.  This can take two distinctly-different forms:  (1) a hypersonic glider vehicle propelled by a large ballistic missile that is staged-off after doing its job,  and (2) a tactical-size hypersonic missile with its rocket propulsion on-board (which does not preclude adding a small staged-off booster rocket).  The range and top speed of the big ballistic missile-boosted concept is not inherently limited,  while the tactical-size vehicle with on-board rocket propulsion is very limited by the weight and volume constraints pertaining to whatever launches it.

However,  if you have a rocket on board the hypersonic vehicle,  you will have to protect it from the heat that conducts inward from the hot lateral skins (and the nose tip and any leading edges).  Same is true of any payload-related items.  These skin surfaces will have to operate in the 1000-1500 F (540-820 C) range in order to radiate enough heat away,  to balance the aeroheating input at stratospheric altitudes,  since the inward conduction simply must be interrupted to protect the rocket (and any other) internal components. 

The maximum recommended service temperature for titanium is 750-800 F (400-430 C).  It is very definitely NOT a high-temperature material,  despite what so many seem to think based on its use in the SR-71.  That vehicle was limited to speeds under Mach 3.3,  it was definitely NOT hypersonic!

Failing that re-radiation balance,  you simply will have to actively-cool those skins!  Why?  It is probably very infeasible to dump such large amounts of inward-conducted heat into the rocket propellant,  particularly if it is solid propellant,  and for several very compelling reasons.  See Figure 1 below. 

Hypersonic Airbreathing Propulsion

If one uses airbreathing propulsion to extend the range of a tactical-size hypersonic vehicle,  that inherently opens multiple further aeroheating problem issues,  that are simply not faced by a rocket vehicle or a glider.  You will (at the very least) have air inlet features and a combustor and nozzle to consider. 

The air capture cowl is aeroheated both inside and outside,  but can effectively radiate only from the outside,  and opportunities for conduction are geometrically absent,  so a higher equilibrium material temperature than a lateral skin is simply inevitable!  Internal inlet ducts obviously cannot radiate to the environment,  and must not conduct inward,  so they will require active cooling!  The combustor and nozzle will also require active cooling,  being either within the airframe unable to radiate,  or else actively aeroheated on the external surface if exposed.  Figure 1 below illustrates these items,  too.

Your choices for airbreathing propulsion are really quite limited:  ramjet,  scramjet,  and some sort of combined cycle propulsion (rocket/turbine,  ramjet/turbine,  or scramjet/turbine).  Turbine alone will simply not work at hypersonic speeds:  the fastest operational gas turbine engine was the short-life design in the Mig-25,  at Mach 3.5 maximum in the stratosphere!  At Mach 5 in the stratosphere,  the captured air temperature exceeds most turbine inlet temperature limits without burning any fuel at all!

Ramjet

Ramjet works quite well at Mach 3 to 4 in the stratosphere,  and can be readily designed to survive Mach 5 speeds with the modern technologies.  If the vehicle is low drag and the ramjet engine is ~100% of the vehicle frontal blockage area,  Mach 6 is demonstrably attainable,  maybe Mach 7.  However,  this is possible only with great difficulty solving the Mach 6-7 aeroheating problems,  especially those associated with the inlet capture,  internal inlet duct,  and inlet duct-mounted fuel injection hardware!  The only currently-viable technology solutions for heat protection at conditions like these are one-shot ablatives.  See References 3 and 4 for lots more information about subsonic-combustion ramjet.

Scramjet

Scramjet may well now be almost ready-to-apply technologically.  It has flown experimentally,  but not yet in vehicles with full aeroheat protections in place.  (Update 8-16-2025:  there may actually be a couple of scramjet missiles out there,  but that technology is still not generally ready for wide application.)  These tests were conducted at altitudes so high that the heat transfer coefficients were reduced by the low air density,  reducing the severity of the thermal management problem for the experimental designs (X-43A and X-51A,  plus an earlier Australian test).  At such altitudes,  airbreather frontal thrust densities are too low to provide any climb rate,  or any acceleration capability in level flight.  These are 100,000 to 130,000 foot (30-40 km).  

That high altitude effect has very serious implications for using airbreathing propulsion for flight-to-orbit,  since the airbreather (any airbreather!) will always have insufficient thrust to fly,  as the air thins further,  just because the ambient pressure is so low!  This is really why the X-30 project failed!  (Rocket actually has slightly higher thrust at altitude than at sea level,  but only if a conventional nozzle is used;  see Reference 5 for why that last statement is true.) 

Combined-Cycle Propulsion Issues

There are two fundamental problems with any (and all) combined-cycle engine designs that use gas turbine as one component.  Problem (1):  the inlet diffuser and nozzle geometries required by the gas turbine are fundamentally incompatible with scramjet (but not necessarily ramjet),  as illustrated in Figure 2 below.  Problem (2):  there must be zero airflow through the turbine component,  once the max safe speed for it (only about Mach 3 to 3.5) is surpassed.  The risk is overheating the turbomachinery.

Regarding problem (1),  gas turbines require low subsonic delivery speed at the compressor face,  which means the post-capture inlet is a divergent diffuser duct that is nearly all-subsonic.  Ramjet demands something similar,  although not geometrically identical.  (See Reference 6 for an explanation of those differences.)  Scramjet demands a nearly constant-area “isolator duct”,  that is all-supersonic to its outlet!  The very small divergence in that “isolator duct” merely offsets boundary layer thickening.  Variable-inlet-geometry hardware is well known to be both voluminous and heavy.  See again Figure 2. 

The turbine outlet speed from a gas turbine is also generally subsonic.  The nozzle must neck-down to a minimum throat area to reach sonic speed,  and may have a very modest supersonic expansion ratio.  Ramjet demands something very similar,  but usually somewhat larger.  Jet fighters use moving “turkey feathers” that are air-cooled to accomplish the throat and exit area variations needed.  Scramjet cannot have a neck-down to a min-area throat,  only a supersonic expansion!   And,  at high supersonic and hypersonic speeds,  there is simply no such thing as “cooling air”,  which means no variable geometry nozzle technological solutions exist in anything resembling a ready-to-apply form!  Again,  see Figure 2.

Regarding problem (2),  there must be designed-in some way to bypass all (ALL!) the inlet air around the gas turbine component,  directly to the ramjet or the scramjet component.  Otherwise,  the hot high-supersonic and hypersonic air will simply destroy the turbomachinery,  even if it is not turning!  This diversion geometry is hard enough to do subsonically for a ramjet component,  and pretty-much technologically impossible to do supersonically for a scramjet component,  due to the shock-down risk.   And,  any such variable geometry inlet hardware is going to be voluminous and heavy,  as already stated.

Rocket-based combined cycles avoid the turbomachinery gas temperature problems.  These are essentially variations on the old ejector ramjet,  and conceptually could transition to scramjet,  if the ramjet uses a thermal choke instead of a physical convergence to a minimum throat area.  However,  no ramjet vehicle ever flew with a thermal choke,  instead always with a physical nozzle!  More than half a century ago,  tests clearly showed that thermal chokes resulted in too low a combustor pressure to ever get any effective performance out of the ramjet.

The true state-of-the-art for these combined cycle approaches is only concept design with finite-element computer analyses.  Not much real testing has been done,  and those results were always less than expected.  The design analyses were (and are) usually made with computational fluid dynamics (CFD),  which is still notoriously subject to both the garbage-in/garbage-out (GIGO) law,  and serious problems recognizing fully-converged numerical solutions. 

Here’s the real problem with CFD models:  there’s a lot more going on inside any engine than just compressible fluid flow with this-or-that turbulence model.  The physics of combustion are usually inadequately modeled,  and the physics of flameholding are usually NOT modeled at all,  in most CFD codes.  Yet these effects really dominate the physics in the engine!  The “gold standard” is thus still real test data with real hardware,  and there is actually precious little of that with most of these concepts. 

That test data objection applies to both the turbine-based and the rocket-based combined-cycle concepts.  These are thus nowhere-near ready-to-fly,  generally speaking.   Which in turn is why you cannot go to a propulsion company,  and just buy one off-the-shelf!  These notions get proposed a lot for government R&D funded efforts,  but none have ever completed any actual development programs.

Effective Propulsion Solutions For Hypersonic Flight

The real solution to these propulsive geometry dilemmas probably has more to do with “parallel burn” of separate propulsion devices,  than with any sort of combined-cycle engine approach.  Another name for “parallel burn” is “mixed propulsion”,  which craft such as the Douglas “Skyrocket”,  the NF-104,  and the XF-91 had.  This took the form of a rocket engine and a gas turbine engine,  on-board separately.

One possible example could be a ramjet vehicle with a built-in rocket booster,  but one able to burn both engines simultaneously after launch and at very high altitudes,  and at landing.  As separate propulsion devices,  the geometry and performance of each component can be optimized.  Forced to share otherwise-incompatible geometries,  both components will inherently end up far from optimal. 

Hypersonic Airbreathing Propulsion for Orbital Ascent?

The real problem is that thrust of an airbreather (any airbreather!),  and the vehicle lift and drag,  are roughly proportional to ambient atmospheric pressure,  while vehicle weight is not!  At very high altitudes in the thin air,  there is not enough lift to oppose the normal weight component,  and not enough thrust-minus-drag net force available to overcome the axial weight component,  and so thus the vehicle fails to fly steady-state,  much less climb and/or accelerate.  This is shown in Figure 3. 

This effect is the source of the “service ceiling” for an aircraft powered by an airbreathing engine (any type of airbreathing engine!).  This is usually specified to be the altitude at which the rate of climb (R/C) falls under about 200 feet per minute,  which is 3.33 ft/sec vertical velocity.  At Mach 5 (about 5000 ft/sec velocity),  that would be a climbing path angle near 0.03 degrees.  At only 500 ft/sec flight velocity (V),  that would be a climb path angle nearer 0.30 degrees.  Neither is very discernible above horizontal. And THAT is the point here:  effectively that is no rate of climb capability,  no matter how long you try.

Lower down,  where the air is thicker,  these forces become far more favorable,  but the aeroheating and drag problems to overcome are far worse.  This is because the heat transfer coefficients are roughly proportional to atmospheric density raised to a fractional power near 0.8,  not 1.  That assessment comes from the usual formulation of the Nusselt number correlations from Reynolds number:  constant x Reynolds number-to-the-0.8 x Prandtl number-to-the-1/3,  for turbulent flow.  See again Figure 3.   

That aeroheating effect and the drag are what drive the need to be at really high altitudes as the vehicle speed approaches orbital values.  Yet for thrust-relative-to-weight purposes,  the airbreather needs to be at very much lower altitudes!  That fundamental design requirements incompatibility is quite stark! 

You overcome it by using rocket propulsion,  not airbreathing propulsion,  at those very high altitudes in the really thin air.  Or at least use rocket propulsion simultaneously with your airbreather.  Yes,  the airbreather makes its thrust at high specific impulse,  but it just does not make very much thrust in that thin air!  The rocket does.  Which is why one should prefer the rocket,  when leaving the atmosphere!

For a two-stage launch system where the first stage is an airplane of some kind,  there are three important variables to consider at your intended staging condition.  In order of importance,  they are (1) highest possible speed,  (2) path angle at about 45 (or more) degrees above horizontal,  and (3) highest possible altitude.  Speed has the greatest beneficial effect,  altitude the least. 

Path angle is important so that the second stage may fly a non-lifting gravity-turn trajectory at minimum drag loss,  to orbit.  Pulling up at high speed is a large-radius turn requiring a lot of gees and incurring a lot of drag-due-to-lift loss due to a very high lift requirement.   If your first stage can do its trajectory to arrive at both high speed and path angle,  that minimizes the second stage drag loss and impulse requirement! 

But,  at all but the very lowest altitudes,  this will require rocket propulsion as the entire propulsion system,  or at least in combination with the airbreather in parallel burn.   No airbreather of any kind used alone will be able to do this kind of beneficial first stage trajectory,  precisely because of the thin-air “service ceiling” effect at higher altitudes.

How Big A Threat Is This New Hypersonic Weapon Stuff,  Really?

So,  there are very good reasons why the new “hypersonic weapons” currently being ballyhooed in the press are just rocket-powered tactical missiles with a peak speed above Mach 5.  Otherwise,  they are just hypersonic gliders dispensed from a large ballistic missile flown on a low,  rather flat,  trajectory.  The “scramjet missiles” are still experimental items,  not really fieldable weapons,  for a while yet. 

The old,  retired AIM-54 “Phoenix” rocket-powered missile had a peak speed of just about Mach 5,  way back in the 1970’s.  So,  what is so “new” or threatening about reprising that?  Nothing!

We have had maneuverable re-entry vehicles as space capsules since the 1960’s,  and as ballistic missile warheads since the 1980’s.  The space shuttle was another.  There is nothing “new” there! 

For the “hypersonic gliders” to be much of a military threat,  the launcher has to fly a much lower entry trajectory,  at a very shallow angle below horizontal,  very unlike the usual strategic ballistic missile.  Otherwise, there is no time to maneuver the glider before it impacts.  That’s just high school physics!

This “new hypersonic glider threat” is really no big deal,  if you know to watch for those depressed ballistic missile trajectories.  And we do.  I just told you,  if no one else did.

References

In addition to the six references cited above,  there is a seventh very useful item,  for those who wish to research this topic further and deeper.  It is included in the list here as Reference 7.  That one contains lists of articles sorted by the topic area. 

One of those topic areas is “aerodynamics and heat transfer articles”,  where I put the high-speed aerothermodynamics stuff,  among some other things.  The hypersonics-related stuff is there,  right up to entry heating models.  There’s also topic areas for “ramjet” and “rocket” stuff,  and much more.  All of these are articles that I wrote and published on this “exrocketman” site over the last several years. 

To find any such article quickly,  use the navigation tool on the left side of the page.  You will need the posting date and the title (jot them down).  Click on the year,  then month,  then the title (if need be). 

You can click on any figure in an article to see enlargements of all of the figures in the article.  There is an X-out option at top right of that page,  which takes you right back to the article itself. Update 8-16-2025:  search codes added to the reference list,  and to the references themselves.  

#1. 2 January 2020,  “High Speed Aerodynamics and Heat Transfer”  (physics and calculation models)  search code 01012020

#2. 12 June 2017,  “Shock Impingement Heating Is Very Dangerous” (physics with X-15 as an example) search code 12062017

#3. 10 December 2016,  “Primer on Ramjets” (basic concepts and fundamentals) search code 10122016

#4. 21 December 2012,  “Ramjet Cycle Analyses”  (how these things are best calculated) search code 21122012

#5. 12 November 2018,  “How Propulsion Nozzles Work” (covers conventional and free-expansion) search code 12112018

#6. 9 November 2020,  “Fundamentals of Inlets” (same components used quite differently for ramjets and gas turbines) search code 09112020

#7. 21 October 2021,  “Lists of Some Articles By Topic Area” (dates and titles arranged by topic) search code 21102021


Figure 1 – Heat Transfer Issues With Hypersonic Flight


Figure 2 – Geometric Incompatibilities Among Airbreathing Concepts For Hypersonic Flight

 

Figure 3 – Thin-Air Effects On Thrust,  Lift,  Drag,  and Aeroheating at High Altitudes

Addendum 6-11-22:

Here is a plot about the flight test space covered by the X-15 program,  relative to the aerodynamic ascent path to low Earth orbit.  The lower altitudes correspond to higher speeds reached by the X-15.  The higher altitudes correspond to lower speeds achieved.  

The X-15A-2 variant was able to reach 4520 mph (Mach 6.7) at 19.3 miles altitude,  still near the left end of that ascent corridor.  It was carrying a scramjet test article on its ventral fin stub during this flight.  The shock wave off the scramjet inlet compression spike nearly cut the tail off the bird from shock impingement heating effects. 

Now bear in mind that shock impingement effects multiply (considerably) the heating rates,  but not the plasma temperatures themselves.  All that means is that the structures affected are going to soak out very quickly,  to very near the plasma driving temperature,  pretty much regardless of what the designer might have done in the way of cooling provisions.  

At the X-15A-2 peak speed conditions,  that plasma sheath temperature was some 3070-3080 F,  far beyond the capability of even the Inconel-X skin material.  The white ceramic coating applied to this particular variant would have been able to do very little about this fast soak-out effect at the shockwave impingement locations.  So,  it is not surprising at all (in retrospect) that the craft suffered so much damage.  


What this figure says so very clearly is that if you fly too high,  you will not get enough lift to fly aerodynamically in such thin air.  And if you fly too low,  you will suffer unendurable aeroheating,  no matter how you attempt to construct your craft.  

And the X-15A-2 experience cited here says that you must avoid any shapes that might cause a shockwave from one structure to impinge upon an adjacent structure.  That absolutely rules out parallel-mounted nacelles.  

It is even worse near the orbital entry point end of the aerodynamic ascent corridor.  That would be about 17,000 mph at about 70 miles altitude.  The estimated plasma sheath driving temperature there is just about 13,200 F.  The peak heating point lies in between these two point (the X-15A-2 test and the orbital entry point).  

Your nosetip and leading edges will have to be ablatives.  And there is no allowing any significant soak-out for lateral skins.  Not at plasma temperatures in the 3000-13,000 F range!

By way of comparison,  the vertically-launched rocket vehicles we currently use to reach orbit (and that includes the Space Shuttle),  leave the sensible atmosphere at about 30 miles,  but only about 1500-2000 mph at that point.  They stay well above the aerodynamic ascent corridor,  essentially flying most of the way in vacuum,  without severe heating.

It is re-entry from orbit that essentially flies this aerodynamic ascent corridor in reverse.  It's just that the exposure times are a lot shorter for entry than they are for ascent.  So the overall heating exposures for aerodynamic ascent are much worse than for entry.

Those are the fundamental things you have to consider,  if you wish to fly an aerodynamic ascent to orbit,  regardless of the propulsion you may be considering. 

Update 6-12-22:

A lot of folks are using the word “hypersonic” very loosely.  Too loosely.  I have even seen the SR-71 termed “hypersonic”,  when it most definitely was not,  at a max allowable cruise speed of Mach 3.2 at some 85,000 feet.  Pilots would pull up and reduce throttle to slow down quickly,  if it ever reached Mach 3.3,  to avoid engine and airframe damage.  I have talked to a couple of them,  and that is what they told me.

There is a formal definition:  “hypersonic” is that speed at which the shape of the shock wave system about the vehicle no longer changes its shape appreciably as flight speed increases further.  The speed at which that happens depends upon the shape of the vehicle. 

For “pointy” shapes likes missiles and aircraft,  it is just about Mach 5,  or a velocity that is 5 times the speed of sound.  For really blunt shapes like space capsules traveling heat shield forward,  it is just about Mach 3.  Those two values are the rules of thumb for “hypersonic”,  for those two classes of shape.

Here is a further update to the figure showing the ascent corridor and the X-15 data.  I have added a typical vertical-launch trajectory,  and some effective temperatures in the plasma sheath about any vehicle.  I also show how precipitously the heat transfer coefficient drops as altitude extremizes.  That is why the peak heating rate point is somewhere in the middle of the ascent corridor,  not its high-speed end.



Thursday, May 26, 2022

Gun Articles as of 5-25-22

We just had another mass shooting at an elementary school.  I have written about this problem as recently as 2017 (see list below),  and so have many others.  That nothing effective has been done during all these years and incidents is abominable!  But judging by what others say about this problem,  there is little agreement about what to do.  I do think that most of the knee-jerk stuff is wrong.

I suggest that any seriously-considered options be data-driven,  or at least have common sense supported by real data,  behind them.  That is what I can offer.  I do have 4 recommendations (highlighted below).  These are data-driven,  and are in accord with common sense.  Please consider them.  Here is the list of past articles:

5-25-22 Gun Articles I Have Written

10-2-17 Machine Guns In Las Vegas

6-21-16 What the Gun Violence Data Really Say

10-7-15 Oregon Mass Shooting and Gun Control

5-31-14 On Calls for More Gun Control

10-1-13 Government Shutdown,  Default!  Again?  No!!!

9-20-13 More Gun Control?  No Way!

2-5-13 Real Problems with the Proposed Gun Control Legislation Items

12-20-12 On the Tragedy in Connecticut

12-14-12 School Shooting in Connecticut

8-9-12 Mass Murder Shooters and Gun Control

1-13-11 On the Shooting Rampage in Tucson

The two best of these are the 10-2-17 and 6-21-16 articles.  The 10-2-17 article outlines what laws apply to possession of machine guns,  and identifies the two “dodges” that get around that restriction.  The 6-21-16 article contains a real analysis of some actual gun violence database data,  to identify two things most likely to be useful for combatting this violence.

 That gets me to 4 recommendations,  that would likely work to one extent or another.  See the two best articles for details.  The first two of these recommendations would have the most beneficial effect.  I think all 4 together might make a real difference.

#1. Fix the really bad legal leak in the process of restricting crazies from getting guns.

#2. Properly defend your gun-free zones.

#3. Update the 1934 law to redefine “machine gun” in terms of rate-of-fire.

#4. Plug the leaks in the background check process. 

I do have real doubts about the effectiveness of any “assault weapons bans”,  both from a past data viewpoint,  and also knowing that so many of these AR-15-type weapons are already “out there”.  You’ll never get them all back,  even if you do ban them.  However,  an age restriction at purchase of such a powerful weapon might help a little bit,  since so many of these school shooters were youngsters with mental issues toting AR-15’s.  Fixing the mental issue leak would do so very much more,  though! 

To easily find any of the articles in the list above,  use the navigation tool on the left side of this page.  Jot down the dates and titles you want to find.  Click on the year,  then on the month,  then on the title if need be.  To see figures enlarged,  just click on any figure to see all of them enlarged.  There is an X-out feature to top right of the page,  which takes you right back to the article.

-------------------

Update 5-31-2022:

For those unwilling  to research further,  here is a short explanation of what my 4 recommendations actually mean. 

#1. Fix the really bad legal leak in the process of restricting crazies from getting guns.

Currently,  there is no record of mental troubles for a background check to uncover,  unless a judge in a court has ruled so.  The popular term “red flag laws” is meant to address this.  But,  what has to happen is to replace the judge-based either-or approach with a graduated approach:  the more indications show up,  the deeper the investigation must probe.  This is not on-line,  it is on-foot go ask friends and relatives.

#2. Properly defend your gun-free zones.

A properly-qualified peace officer must be able to respond within 1 minute,  and he must not be out-gunned.  Arming teachers will not suffice,  they are not properly-qualified peace officers.  Properly-qualified peace officers are not qualified teachers.  Plus,  there’s more than just schools to protect.

#3. Update the 1934 law to redefine “machine gun” in terms of rate-of-fire.

That would automatically outlaw trigger cranks and bump stocks,  plus any other such inventions in the future. 

#4. Plug the leaks in the background check process.

If you do not,  then there is a way around the first 3 suggestions that bad actors will exploit.


Tuesday, May 24, 2022

Diet Joke

 I stole this one from the funnies page of the American Legion magazine for May 2022.  It's just funny.  So enjoy!



Why is a diet called a "diet"?



Because all the other four-letter words were taken.

Sunday, May 1, 2022

Investigation: “Big Ship” Propellant From the Moon vs From Earth

This article is a follow-on to my earlier article (Ref. 1) about “big ship” propulsion for a large orbit-to-orbit transport between Earth and Mars.  The question has arisen:  “would it be better to make the propellant on the moon and ship it to low Earth orbit (LEO),  instead of shipping it up to LEO from the Earth’s surface?”  This article tries to answer that question,  at least in part. 

There are a lot of things that would impact any such propellant-making infrastructure on the moon.  The most important is “what resources are available with which to do this?”  One almost as important is “what is the difference between a resource-in-theory and an easily-recoverable resource?”.  Unfortunately,  too few consider that second question. 

Consider this:  there are oxygen and hydrogen atoms,  and some metal atoms,  locked up in the molecules making up the minerals that in turn compose the rocks and rock dust on the moon.  Those are “resources-in-theory”,  yes,  but they are most decidedly NOT “easily recoverable resources”.  To obtain them you would have to destroy the molecules into their individual atoms,  in order to separate-out what you want. 

What that really means is that you must turn solid rock particles into fully ionized,  fully dissociated plasma.  That takes a whopping amount of energy to do,  even on a small quantity,  and you would use far,  far more energy doing it,  than you could ever recover by burning the recovered atoms as propellants in some engine.  There is NO WAY AROUND that conundrum!

An easily-recoverable resource might well exist on the moon:  ice deposits.  There seem to be ices mixed into the regolith at least in the permanently-shadowed craters at the moon’s south pole,  and possibly elsewhere on the moon.  You merely need to physically separate the ice from the regolith,  melt it,  purify it if it is contaminated with salt or something else,  then electrolyze it for hydrogen and oxygen gases,  that you can then liquify to use as propellants. 

There doesn’t seem to be much in the way of carbon atoms on the moon,  certainly not as “easily-recoverable resources”.  What that means is that you cannot readily make methane fuel on the moon,  unless you import soot or carbon black from elsewhere,  such as from Earth.  But,  if the ice can really be found,  you can make liquid oxygen and liquid hydrogen as propellants on the moon.

In my previous article,  I looked at liquid oxygen-liquid methane as my chemical propellant combination,  something that cannot be readily made on the moon.  Most of the nuclear options use liquid hydrogen,  which can be readily made on the moon,  given ice to mine.  The electric propulsion items currently flying use things other than oxygen or hydrogen as their propellants.  The nuclear explosion drive uses fissionable materials,  something not yet found on the moon as a resource we can readily exploit.

That leaves liquid oxygen-liquid hydrogen chemical propulsion,  and the hydrogen-based nuclear thermal rocket options,  as something we could support with propellant-making infrastructure on the moon.  Nothing else seems to qualify. 

Therefore,  what I will evaluate here is the solid-core nuclear thermal (NERVA) concept for a “big ship” orbit-to-orbit transport,  using hydrogen delivered to LEO from the moon (versus shipped-up from Earth’s surface).  That delivery uses liquid oxygen-liquid hydrogen chemical propulsion to do the delivery from the moon,  appropriate in terms of boiloff risks because of the short flight times. 

That would seem to be the best fit,  to what might actually be an “easily-recoverable resource” (water ice) on the moon.  Emplacing the infrastructure to do this on the moon,  would be far easier than emplacing similar infrastructure on Mars,  because the moon is only 3-5 days away at a lower one-way delta-vee (dV),  versus Mars being several months away at a higher dV.

Picking a Delivery System Design

There would be a lot of ways to do this.  But,  the most reusable might be a delivery stage operating between LEO and low lunar orbit (LLO).  How such a stage is refilled at the moon is the real question here.  The most straightforward answer would be to land the stage,  refill it on the surface,  and relaunch it to LLO.  The most efficient way to do that,  would be to add a separate ferry stage that does the landings and takeoffs,  carrying the transfer stage as its dead-head payload.  That ferry stage never leaves LLO,  except to land on the surface,  refill,  reload,  and take off again. 

What are the Requirements?

The moon circles the Earth in an elliptic orbit of low eccentricity:  not quite circular,  but fairly close.  This affects the perigee and apogee speeds of any transfer orbit from Earth to the moon.  The non-circular lunar orbit effects are not large,  but they are quite real,  as depicted in Figure 1.  What I have shown is the 2-body approximation that led to the figure-8 trajectory into retrograde lunar orbit that was used by Apollo.  The moon spins so slowly that the retrograde LLO orbit penalty is trivial. 

Figure 1 – Basic Astronomical Data Regarding Earth and Moon Orbits and Transfers

A craft approaching the moon on a transfer ellipse has an apogee speed far less than the moon’s orbital speed about the Earth,  as indicated in the figure.  In effect,  the moon is trying to “run over” the craft from behind.  The difference between these speeds is the craft’s speed with respect to (wrt) the moon,  before any effects of the moon’s gravity come into play. 

There is an approximation to this “third-body effect” of the moon,  shown in Figure 2.  That is the “far” versus “near” speed estimates relative to the moon.  But,  to get this “right”,  requires an orbital trajectory analysis computer program that can handle 3 (or more) bodies interacting gravitationally.  That is where the Apollo figure-8 trajectory actually came from.

As noted in the figure,  I used a nominal 300 km altitude for LEO,  and a nominal 100 km altitude for LLO.  These values are consistent with typical practices here at Earth,  and with the Apollo experience at the moon.  At Earth,  the difference between the transfer orbit perigee velocity,  and the circular orbit velocity at 300 km altitude,  is the dV required to depart (or arrive) at Earth. 

It’s a bit more complicated at the moon,  because of the 3rd-body approximation,  and having to obtain speeds with respect to the moon.  This in indicated in the figure.  For purposes of evaluation,  a nominal arrival/departure dV in LEO would be about 3.110 km/s.  A similar nominal arrival/departure dV in LLO would be near 0.830 km/s.  The gravity and drag loss-factored dV to get from Earth’s surface to LEO is some 8.705 km/s.  The gravity loss-factored dV to get from the moon’s surface to LLO is about 1.819 km/s.  Course correction budgets and rendezvous budgets have yet to be considered.

Figure 2 – Processing Astronomical Values into Rocket dV Requirements

Figure 3 shows the nominal dV values associated with the transfer stage flying to and from Earth,  to include an assumed dV budget for multiple course correction burns along the way,  each way.  As the figure indicates,  on the trip from LLO to LEO,  the transfer stage is heavy with propellant,  being completely full at departure from LLO.

The same dV’s apply to the return from LEO to LLO,  except that the transfer stage arrives depleted of all propellants in LLO.  One thing to remember is that some propellant is off-loaded while in LEO!  That off-loaded propellant is the “payload” delivered from the moon to LEO,  for loading into the “big ship”.  

Figure 3 – Determining Delta-Vee Requirements for a Transfer Stage/Ferry Stage System

What is not shown in the figure is the rendezvous budget needed by the ferry stage between the lunar surface and LLO.  This is not needed for launch,  since the transfer stage is the dead-head payload pushed by the ferry stage.  It is needed for lunar arrivals,  as the ferry stage must find the transfer stage in LLO,  then rendezvous and dock with it,  in order to carry it back down to the lunar surface.  There,  both are refilled for the next flight.

The rendezvous budget adds to the surface-LLO dV of 1.819 km/s,  but only for ferry stage upon transfer stage arrival.  Being airless,  for the ferry stage at the moon,  the basic factored landing dV is the same as the factored launch dV = 1.819 km/s,  as shown in the figure.  So,  with a rendezvous budget of 0.1 km/s,  the factored landing dV = 1.919 km/s.  This is shown in Figure 4.  Factoring reflects 0.825% gravity loss.

For the ferry stage,  these two burns occur at different weight statements.  As explained in Ref. 1,  you have to do two separate rocket equation calculations for these burns,  precisely because of the difference in weight statements.  You do the second burn first,  so that its propellant is part of the burnout mass for the first burn. 

The total propellant mass needed for the two burns is what sets the ferry stage stage inert mass,  easily estimated from the ferry stage-only propellant mass fraction R assumed for the analysis.  What I assumed for chemical propulsion in Ref. 1 (R = 0.97),  is not what I will assume here for this chemical propulsion stage.  While boiloff effects are far higher with liquid hydrogen,  flight times are far shorter.  However,  this ferry stage needs landing legs and the structural “beef” to support the transfer stage.  I used R = 0.97 for the transfer stage,  and R = 0.90 for the ferry stage. 

Figure 4 – Delta-Vee and Weight Statement Information for the Ferry Stage

The transfer stage is the dead-head payload for the ferry stage.  Thus,  it has to be defined first,  so that appropriate dead-head masses can be used in the rocket equation analysis of the ferry stage.  What that means is one sizes the transfer stage first,  then the ferry stage.    Appropriate dV and weight statement information for the transfer stage are given in Figure 5.  This includes course correction budgets.  The big item here is just how much liquid hydrogen is off-loaded in LEO for loading into the NERVA-powered “big ship”.  This is very probably best done as an off-load to an orbiting propellant depot facility,  for later loading into the “big ship”.  Ref. 2 is my take on what such an orbital propellant depot facility might look like.  The value I chose (500 metric tons) is arbitrary!

What that means is that the incoming-to-LEO transfer stage needs a rendezvous budget to meet up with either the on-orbit propellant depot or the “big ship” itself.  Since Earth’s gravity well is stronger and its orbital speeds are higher,  I used 0.2 km/s for that course correction budget instead of the 0.1 km/s I used at the moon.  The figure reflects that. 

The independent variable here is just how much liquid hydrogen I am going to off-load in LEO as payload,  to be loaded (immediately or eventually) into the “big ship”.  The smaller that number,  the more “reasonable” will the ferry and transfer stage sizes be,  but the higher the number of required flights will be,  from the moon.  That choice is entirely arbitrary,  and I have no clue how best to set it. 

If I use about 6000-8000 tons of liquid hydrogen in a NERVA-powered big ship also refilled at Mars,  per the recommendations from Ref. 1,  and I want no more than about 12 or 16 flights from the moon to refill it,  that would set the off-loaded liquid hydrogen “payload” number at around 500 metric tons per flight from the moon.  And that totally-inadequate estimate is the “best” that I have at this time.  

Figure 5 – Delta-Vee and Weight Statement Information for the Transfer Stage

Stage Sizing Results

Figure 6 shows both the spreadsheet image and a pictorial sketch for the sized transfer stage.  It operates between LLO and LEO,  and offloads 500 metric tons of its propellant while in LEO,  to serve its tanker function.  This stage does not land itself upon the moon for refill,  nor does it get serviced by a tanker up from the moon’s surface.  It is the dead-head payload for a ferry stage that operates between the lunar surface and LLO. 

Figure 7 shows both the spreadsheet image and a pictorial sketch for the sized lunar ferry stage.  It operates between the lunar surface and LLO,  with the transfer stage as its dead-head payload.  Because this stage must support the transfer stage,  and because it must have landing legs,  I significantly reduced the stage propellant mass fraction for this design.  It takes off with the transfer stage fully loaded,  and it lands with the transfer stage fully depleted.  It needs a rendezvous budget to meet and dock with the transfer stage,  but only after the transfer stage returns to LLO,  before landing. 

The fact that these two stages are roughly about the same size suggests that this design approach is probably not very far from an optimum.  It takes about 2385.1 metric tons of LOX-LH2 propellant made on the moon to deliver 500 tons of propellant to LEO.  That ratio is 4.770:1,  which is even more favorable than shipping up propellant from Mars.  That outcome is not so surprising,  since the moon has a far shallower gravity well than Earth.  Thus there is plenty of capability to travel between LEO and LLO,  as well as for shipping propellant up from the lunar surface to LLO.  That 4.77 ratio (ton for ton) is quite a bit more attractive than the estimated ratio shipping propellant up from the surface of the Earth (26.9),  by a factor of roughly 5! 

Figure 6 – Sized Transfer Stage LLO-LEO for Delivery of 500 Tons Propellant to LEO from the Moon

Figure 7 – Sized Ferry Stage to Take Transfer Stage To-and-From Lunar Surface From LLO

Using the NERVA “Big Ship” Study As a Comparison Basis

The best NERVA configuration for the “big ship” was a one-way design refilled at Mars,  using a NERVA-powered space tug and an elliptic capture orbit,  to assist with Earth departures and arrivals.  This minimized both Earth and Mars propellant manufacturing quantities and rates.  The real emphasis on that selection was minimizing the infrastructure needed on Mars.  However,  the same held true when making and shipping the propellant from the moon to LEO.

The total propellant manufacturing quantities per “big ship” mission are compared in Figure 8.  These totals are propellant deliveries to LEO (and to LMO),  plus all the launch and transfer propellant needed to get it there,  at both planets.  All the NERVA-powered “big ship” scenarios from the original study are there,  and making propellant on the moon versus on Earth does not change the selection of the “best” option:  refill at Mars,  use a space tug only at Earth (scenario 4). 

However,  making propellant on the moon and shipping it to LEO makes almost a factor-5 reduction on the Earth total propellant quantity!  The total quantities to make and ship-up at Mars are unchanged by the Earth vs lunar choice.  This mission looks far more attractive,  using the lunar propellant option. 

That does require emplacing significant propellant manufacturing infrastructure on the moon,  in turn pre-supposing that ground truth will verify the presence of easily-recoverable ice resources there.  It will be far easier to construct infrastructure on the moon,  which is only 3-5 days away,  than it will be on Mars,  which is 6-9 months away.  That is why selecting option 4 is the best choice available,  once one presumes that at least some propellant-making infrastructure at all must emplaced on Mars.

The other issue is exactly where those easily-recoverable ice resources will be located on the moon.  For this study,  I presumed equatorial locations.  If polar,  the higher dV will raise the launch-and-ship/delivered propellant ratio from 4.77 to something a little higher.  But it will still be attractive. 

Figure 8 – Propellant Quantities Comparisons For Ship-Up From Earth vs Ship From Moon

The manufacturing rates comparison is given in Figure 9.  It tells basically the same tale as Figure 8,  plus the far more reasonable rate numbers that will in part size any propellant-making infrastructure on the moon and on Mars.  These are simply the total quantity numbers divided by the 52 month interval between successive missions flown by the “big ship”,  as indicated in the original Ref. 1 article.  

Figure 9 – Propellant Rates Comparisons For Ship-Up From Earth vs Ship From Moon

“Tanker Flights” Required

This study presumes the use of the SpaceX Starship/Superheavy as the supply tanker for shipping propellant up from Earth’s surface to LEO,  at 171 metric tons deliverable per flight.  To fill the NERVA-powered “big ship” in LEO from the surface requires something like 51 tanker flights!  Plus something similar to refill the tug. 

At 500 tons per flight from the moon,  something like only 17 or 18 transfer/ferry stage flights are required to LEO from the lunar surface,  which is far more reasonable to expect!  Doing propellant from the moon really does make a large improvement for this kind of “big ship” transport mission.  It just presumes the necessary easily-recovered resources really are there,  on the moon,  for us to exploit.  That is not yet determined to be true with real ground truth.

At Mars,  this study presumes the SpaceX Starship is flown single stage,  at about 200 metric tons delivered to LMO.  Something near 12 tanker flights are needed at Mars to refill the “big ship” while it is there.   That’s not too bad,  really!  This also presumes the easily-recovered ice resources really are there to exploit.  That still requires confirmation with real ground truth,  although the remote sensing is promising indeed.

The tanker issue is affected by the 500 ton choice I made for sizing vehicles.  Fewer flights are required if that offload-payload is larger,  but the sized vehicles are also larger,  and because the ferry stage has to land with the transfer stage as its payload,  the square-cube scaling laws versus intrinsic material strengths get involved in the design.  There is an unaddressed optimization lurking behind that question.

Explanation Of How These Stages Operate

Just to make these concepts perfectly clear,  see Figure 10.  The ferry stage never leaves the moon.  It waits in LLO,  after launching with the full transfer stage,  until the transfer stage arrives in LLO,  now empty.  The ferry stage rendezvouses and docks,  then carries the transfer stage back to the lunar landing site,  where both are refilled with propellants made on the moon. 

The transfer stage is full for its departure burn from LLO.  It does make a course correction burn,  then an arrival burn into LEO.  In LEO,  500 metric tons of propellant are off-loaded for eventual loading into the “big ship”.  The transfer stage then burns to depart LEO,  makes a small course correction,  and then an arrival burn into LLO,  which depletes its propellant.  The ferry stage then docks with it,  and takes it to the lunar surface for refill of both stages.

The transfer stage has the larger dV requirement,  but the lower burnout mass,  by far.  The ferry stage has a substantially lower dV requirement,  but has the much higher burnout mass,  carrying the transfer stage as payload,  particularly at launch,  when the transfer stage is full. 

Figure 10 – Illustration of How These Stages Operate

Some Notions of the Engine Thrust Requirements

I did take a rough shot at sizing actual engines for these stages.  The transfer stage never goes anywhere but out in space,  in orbits about Earth and the moon,  and the transfer orbit between them.  I used a time limit on the burn to ensure it is impulsive.  The 6 minute figure I used is more-or-less arbitrary,  but falls in the range of 5-7% of the orbital period about the Earth or the moon. 

The dV divided by that time is an acceleration needed,  which worked out to be between 80-90% of a standard gee.  That and the max mass,  sized the max engine thrust.  The same acceleration applied to the min mass provided an estimate of min thrust.  I chose an engine thrust and a number of engines such that max thrust occurs with all engines running near 100% throttle,  and the min thrust with one engine running at roughly 50% thrust.

The ferry stage sizes more by the kinematics of the takeoff fully loaded.  To get good kinematics,  the thrust to local weight ratio should equal or exceed 1.5,  as a really good rule of thumb.  I used 2 for this.  And again,  I sized the max thrust per engine and number of engines at 100% setting,  and the min thrust near 50% setting on only one engine,  in turn acting upon an unfactored weight,  which allows it to settle for landing.

One can always argue with my exact numbers,  but that is what I did.  See Figure 11 for the results.  

Figure 11 – Rough Estimates of Engine Thrust Requirements for These Stages

Misc. Remarks

An unaddressed issue remains,  one which I chose not to address here.  The transfer stage is going to need to execute a rendezvous and dock procedure with either the “big ship” or an on-orbit propellant depot.  It needs to do this,  in order to offload the 500 tons of propellant usefully. 

I did not include a rendezvous-and-dock allowance on the dV value I used to size this stage.  However,  the course correction budgets are probably overkill,  so in that sense,  I have it “sort-of” covered.  That is why I chose not to go back and change all these numbers,  just to include that allowance.

Conclusions

#1. Lunar-made propellant shipped to LEO would seem to make many of the orbit-to-orbit “big ship” transport scenarios far more favorable in terms of propellant quantities and rates.  This is a mission nuance every bit as important as the space tug concepts explored in Ref. 1.   

#2. To do this lunar-made propellant thing requires emplacing significant propellant-manufacturing infrastructure on the moon (and also on Mars).  Any such facility,  at either location,  will need to produce a few hundred to several hundred tons of propellant each month.

#3. It seems quite unlikely that LCH4 can be produced on the moon,  because of a lack of easily-recoverable carbon;  LH2 and LOX seem very likely,  provided that real ground truth reveals easily-recoverable ice resources are available. “Easily recoverable” does not mean 1-or-2% moisture content in regolith,  it means more-or-less massive buried ice deposits.  That’s a few hundred kilograms per day,  or several kilograms per hour,  guys!  The grams-per-hour demonstrator hardware items are simply several orders of magnitude outside the ballpark we need to be playing in. 

#4. LH2 has a much higher boiloff risk compared to LCH4.  LOX-LH2 chemical is not very attractive for the “big ship” to Mars,  precisely because of that risk,  and the months-long flight times.  If that issue had a ready-to-fly solution,  the outcome would be different:  LOX-LH2 chemical would be feasible,  and would fall in between the LOX-LCH4 chemical and the LH2 NERVA options evaluated in Ref. 1.

#5. LH2 would support NERVA or any of the gas core concepts for the “big ship” propulsion;  it might even support electric,  if a hydrogen-fueled variant can be developed and scaled up.  But,  for any of these options,  it is simply required that the LH2 boiloff risk can be handled acceptably-well!  We need a ready-to-fly solution to this problem!  We do not yet have one!

#6. This analysis presumed an equatorial location for the propellant station on the moon.  Things look less favorable,  but very likely still attractive,  if a polar location is really required,  driving-up the dV required surface-to-LLO,  and thereby raising the ratio of launch-and-transfer propellant to the propellant deliverable on-orbit in LEO.  

References

#1.  G. W. Johnson,  “Earth-Mars Orbit-to-Orbit Transport Propulsion Studies”,  posted 2 April 2022,  on http://exrocketman.blogspot.com.  (There is an associated PowerPoint presentation.)

#2.  G. W. Johnson,  “A Concept For an On-Orbit Propellant Depot”,  posted 1 February 2022,  on http://exrocketman.blogspot.com.

To find things easily on the “exrocketman” site,  use the navigation tool on the left.  All you need is the posting date and the title.  Click on the year,  then on the month,  then on the title,  if need be. 

You can see enlargements of all the figures in any article by clicking on any one of them.  There is an X-out option to upper right,  that takes you back to the article.