Showing posts with label radiation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label radiation. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 31, 2026

About the Artemis-2 Mission

Update 10-15-2026:  See the 28 April 2026 article "Preliminary Evaluation of Artemis-2 Heat Shield" for an update added this date,  showing a new photo from Steve Yoon at NASA.  

-----   

See the 4-13-2026 update at the end,  for some early photos of Artemis-2 post landing,  plus my preliminary assessment of heat shield damage from them.

------------   

The following picture is a NASA illustration of the mission.  It does not give reliable distances,  nor does it show when the vehicle crosses,  or is outside,  the Van Allen radiation belts.  Outside the Van Allen belts,  the vehicle is also outside the Earth’s magnetic field,  and therefore at risk for radiation exposure,  should a solar flare’s coronal mass ejection (CME) event occur,  and happen to hit them.  


The next two figures together show the sequence of actual orbits being used,  after I looked around to various sources on line,  for real distance information.  I could not fit all the information into one figure.  That is why there are two figures that I hand-drew.

The NASA space launch system (SLS) rocket is a two-stage launch vehicle whose first stage core is assisted by two large solid boosters (SRB’s),  as was the space shuttle.  This first stage booster and its SRB’s essentially put the interim cryogenic propellant second stage (ICPS),  plus Orion capsule and its service module (SM),  onto a transfer ellipse with an apogee at the desired apogee altitude,  and a perigee that is pretty close to being a surface-grazing orbit.  There is no second stage ICPS burn to get onto that transfer ellipse. 

The ICPS makes a small burn at that desired apogee,  which raises the perigee up to the desired perigee altitude just outside the atmosphere,   but still quite low.  That apogee is actually within the inner of the two Van Allen radiation belts!    Without that perigee-raising burn at the initial apogee,  the Orion would inevitably re-enter the atmosphere on its first-pass return to perigee! 

The ICPS second stage then makes another,  larger burn at the newly-raised perigee point,  which raises the apogee to a very high elliptical orbit apogee,  actually outside both of the Van Allen belts.  They extend from about 1000 km,  to over 50,000 km,  altitudes.

The ICPS stage then makes one last “small” burn to put it into a “graveyard orbit”.  That graveyard orbit was not defined anywhere that I could access,  so I could not determine the magnitude of that burn.  All of this that I could find,  is in my first hand-drawn figure,  here: 


My second hand-drawn figure just below shows the transition from this high elliptic orbit to the actual transfer trajectory to the moon.  I used an ellipse from the low 185 km perigee at Earth to an apogee at the average distance of the moon to approximate the actual figure-8 trajectory,  for the purpose of estimating the departure delta-vee (dV) supplied by the Orion Service Module (SM) propulsion.  That dV is shown in that second hand-drawn figure. 

The actual transfer trajectory starts with this ellipse,  but gets distorted into the figure-8 shape by the gravity of the moon passing by,  making those details a 3-body problem one can only solve by finite-difference methods on the computer.  It loops around the moon in almost a polar orientation,  somewhere near 6500 km altitude,  behind the moon.  Then it free-returns to Earth.  A minor course correction from the SM is needed,  just before it gets jettisoned,  to ensure hitting Earth’s atmosphere at just the right angle,  for the free-return direct entry.


That direct re-entry returning from the moon is more demanding than one from low Earth orbit like the space shuttle endured,  because the speed at entry interface (about 140 km altitude) is higher,  at essentially the perigee speed of the transfer ellipse model shown above,  or right at 10.94 km/s,  maybe even 10.98 km/s.  That speed is very nearly Earth escape speed,  which is 11.18 km/s at the surface,  and 11.07 km/s at the entry interface altitude of 140 km.  Only about 90 to 130 m/s different!

The test history of the Orion capsule and its heat shield points to a disturbing possibility of heat shield damage possibly happening on this Artemis-2 mission!  The first Orion flew atop a Delta-IV launch vehicle uncrewed,  for a re-entry test,  among other things.  This was before Artemis,  and was named experimental flight test 1,  or EFT-1.  It had a heat shield manufactured of the same materials,  and built exactly the same way,  as the Apollo heat shields.  It did fine,  but that is an expensive,  labor-intensive manufacturing process. 

NASA used the same basic ablative material,  but manufactured in a completely different way,  for building two Orion capsules at once:  designated for the Artemis-1 and -2 missions.  They built the Artemis-2 heat shield before flight-testing the revised manufacturing process for it on the uncrewed Artemis-1,  launched by an SLS rocket.    They expected it to do fine,  but it did not,  unexpectedly shedding chunks of char,  leaving craters in the heat shield,  as the photo just below shows.  This is an official NASA photo of the Artemis-1 heat shield,  as recovered after the uncrewed Artemis-1 flight. 


The streaks on the heat shield point to a “source”,  to photo right on the heat shield,  which would be the stagnation point deliberately located off-center,  for generating a slight lift force during entry.  That force is small,  but it can “fine tune” the re-entry trajectory shape,  by rolling the vehicle to point that force where you want it.  NASA has done this for decades,  dating back to the Gemini flights of the mid 1960’s.  That is normal.

But,  if you look close,  you can see “craters”,  some large,  some small,  all over that heat shield,  where it shed chunks of the charred material from its surface!  That outcome was entirely unexpected,  and led to serious investigations at NASA,  for what to do about it. 

It must also be said that these damage craters,  as they were experienced on Artemis-1,  were not a risk for a fatal burn through!  The interior temperatures in the cabin did not vary from normal and expected,  despite the alarming damage!

NASA decided from its investigations that the two-heating-pulse “skip” entry,  that they used experimentally for Artemis-1,  was the culprit behind the chunk-shedding,  thinking that charring-material gas-evolution during the second heating pulse is what “blew” these chunks out,  leaving the craters behind.  They eliminated the skip during re-entry for Artemis-2,  getting it down to 1 heating pulse,  and decided to fly the same heat shield design,  already installed on the Artemis-2 capsule,  with a crew.

Others are not so sure about that damage mechanism.  We shall soon see. 

If Artemis-2 shows similar damage to Artemis-1,  then we (and NASA) will know that they were wrong about this damage mechanism!  Only a flight test can tell!

The problem here is shedding a second chunk from the bottom of one of the larger craters.  Should that happen,  the probability of a fatal burn through becomes very significant indeed!   Such would be a very low-probability event,  but that probability is not zero!

Last year,  I sent my concerns about this problem,  plus a low-cost means to stop the chunk-shedding,  even for a two-pulse skip re-entry,  to the entry heat protection group at NASA-Houston,  and again this year directly to the new Administrator,  at his DC office.  I do know that the Houston heat protection group thought I was right about my concern,  and about my proposed “fix”. 

So far,  NASA has not officially chosen to explore my alternative,  and,  as near as I can tell,  has already started construction of the Artemis-3 capsule with the same Artemis-1/Artemis-2 heat shield design.

Personally,  I would not ask a crew to fly with an unresolved risk that I already thought that I knew how to mitigate!  I think that is unethical!  Apparently,  there are high-level managers at NASA who disagree with that assessment. 

All I can say to them is this:  “there is nothing as expensive as a dead crew,  especially one dead from a bad management decision”.

What I sent the new Administrator is what was posted here on “exrocketman” 1 March 2026,  under the title “Ramjet Data Re:  Heat Shields”.  I knew a lot about ablative heat protection in ramjets and in solid rockets.  Some of that overlaps re-entry heat shields!

I did the 2-body ellipse orbital calculations illustrated here,  with a simple Excel spreadsheet “orbit basics spreadsheet.xlsx”,  which is part of the course materials posted online for free download,  via the Mars Society’s New Mars forums.  It simply automates the classic 2-body textbook equations.  While that New Mars forums site is down as of this writing,  you can still get that spreadsheet from me.  Just email me for it.  Anybody can do what I did here.

-----   
search code DDMMYYYY format:   31032026
search keywords:  aerothermo, launch, radiation, space program
-----   

Update 4-11-2026:  They made it back safe.  Of that I am glad.  I am eagerly awaiting photos of the condition of their heat shield.  Once I see such,  I will update here again.

-----   

Update 4-13-2026:  Enough photos have surfaced of the Artemis-2 heat shield to make a preliminary assessment.  Starting with Figure A,  which is too blurry to make out very much,  other than the side facing the camera is not the side with the hatch and windows.  There is one tie-down pad zone that seems to have suffered damage (the whitish thing near the rim.  The other one near it did not,  being the slightly-dark spot below it and to its right,  also near the rim.  The other two tie-down pads are not in this view.   It is unclear whether the capsule is being hoisted,  or is still descending on its main chutes.

Figure A – View of Artemis-2 Orion Capsule

Figure B is a clearer version but of limited view dimension,  probably enhanced for clarity,  and apparently made from the blurry photo in Figure A,  intended to examine the whitish hold down pad damage.  It looks like a cavity in the heat shield,  burned out around where that hold-down pad got destroyed. 

To its left and lower left,  I see 4 dark,  small cavities that appear to be craters left behind from char chunks lost,  similar to those seen on the Artemis-1 heat shield.  They are just smaller and fewer than the hundred or so seen on Artemis-1.  Bear in mind that these few are on a small portion of the entire heat shield!  There could well be several,  to many, more!

Up on the lateral side of the capsule,  where the Avcoat protection was thinner,  I do see exposed metal in at least two places,  where the charred heat shielding was lost,  and that exposed metal looks distorted,  as if it did indeed see overheating during entry.

Figure B – Detail Near Hold-Down Pad Damage,  Enhanced for Clarity

Figure C is a photo taken during the post-splashdown extraction of the crew.   This is on the other side of the capsule,  where the windows and the hatch are located,  opposite side from that examined in Figures A and B.   The heat shield itself is hidden in this view.  I wish to point out that the lateral side of the capsule suffered very much less apparent damage than that seen in Figure B.  It would appear that the Figure B side saw more attached flow due to maneuvering angle-of-attack,  than the Figure C side,  thus charring the thinner lateral tiles through,  and so losing some of them.  

Figure C – Photo Taken During Crew Extraction,  Other Side of Capsule

The last figure,  Figure D below,  is NOT of an Orion capsule,  but an Apollo capsule,  specifically the one from Apollo-11.  In it,  one can very clearly see the reinforcing hex in the heat shield charred surface,  plus a variety of plugs that close openings in that heat shield. 

Similar to Orion,  there is more erosion near the “compression shear pad”  (same function as the “hold down pad” on Orion.  That kind of thing is apparently not unexpected. 

What I want to point out is the oxidizer dump plug,  which does not seem to have had any hex in it.  That location shows more erosion than the heat shield around it,  which emphasizes the positive reinforcement function served by the hex.  

Figure D – Minor Damages Seen on the Apollo-11 Heat Shield

My conclusions are three-fold: 

(1) Beneficial erosion reduction was indeed obtained by deleting the two-heating-pulse skip entry,  just as thought by NASA. 

(2) While erosion was reduced by deleting the skip,  there was still some char chunk-shedding going on,  which NASA hoped would not happen.  Plus,  there was some damage to the lateral side of the capsule. 

(3) The need for the reinforcing hex has been apparent since Apollo,  which did NOT do skip entries.

My recommendation still stands:  NASA,  put the reinforcing hex into your Avcoat tiles.  Use the extrusion press the way I suggested,  to do that without manual hand-gunning.  

-----   

Update 4-20-2026:  I have been able to confirm that Figure A just above is indeed a CBS-taken photo of Artemis-2 still hanging from its chutes,  just immediately prior to splashdown.  That one is blurry,  and shows a white splotch near the rim that sparked a lot of questions and discussions.  I am inferring that CBS did digital enhancement to clear up the blurriness,  and zoom-in on the white splotch.  That would be Figure B just above.  It is quite clearly derived from the original in Figure A.  

What I see is essentially a lot of unexpected lateral-side damage in Figure B,  plus some cracking and about 4 small chunk-loss craters,  on a very small portion of the main bottom of the heat shield.  

What I have noticed is that NASA has not jumped to release photos taken all over that heat shield,  to quiet the fears sparked by the Artemis-1 damage.  The only ones we have seen show the lateral side with the windows and hatch,  where things look quite good.  None show the other lateral side where there was attached flow with higher heating while flying at angle-of-attack,  and none show the main heat shield on the bottom.  

My suspicion remains:  I think there was still some chunk-loss cratering,  and cracking,  on the main heat shield bottom,  just fewer craters,  and of smaller size.  So it really did do better with the revised trajectory,  just not good enough!

I have a new suspicion:  the damage on the back lateral side threatens a burn-through into the pressure cabin shell inside,  and was apparently quite unexpected.  Deleting the skip increased the peak heating load,  and that may have been a bit too much for that backside lateral wall,  where flow was attached at angle of attack,  causing a lot more "scrubbing action".  

If I am right,  neither suspicion threatens Artemis-3,  which is an Earth-orbital mission that sees far less heating upon re-entry.  But is does threaten Artemis-4,  the intended first landing mission to the moon.  It must return from the moon just like Artemis-2 just did.  

They really,  really need to fix this heat shield problem "right" before Artemis-4 flies!  Otherwise,  they are playing the odds with crews' lives.  Sooner or later,  that kills crews.  We have already seen it!

-----   

Update 4-23-2026:  Here are some more photos that have surfaced since the Artemis-2 splashdown.  We have not yet seen anything “official” about Artemis-2’s heat shield condition and performance from NASA,  not as of this writing! 

Figure I below is supposed to be a photo taken of lateral-wall damage seen,  as pointed out by the mission commander Reid Wiseman.  I do not know exactly where this photo came from!  The tan color surface is stuff that is almost unheated.  The black stuff is material that saw enough heating to actually char.   There is some sort of localized crater in the lateral wall heat shield that he is pointing to. 

Note the black thing near his head in the image.  That is either the hatch opening or one of the recessed windows,  which would have been in the separated flow region on the opposite side of the capsule,  from where the stagnation point was biased toward the rim. 

Damages might well have been more severe on the other side of the capsule,  adjacent to the stagnation point that was offset toward the rim,  where heating would have been much higher.  We do not know:  no images from there have been released by NASA.

We have seen (so far) no images of the other side of the capsule at all,  where flow was attached and heating higher,   other than in the unofficial enhanced CBS image taken just before splashdown. 

Figure II below is a NASA photo taken of the heat shield by the Navy divers,  while the capsule was still in the water,  probably before the astronauts were recovered,  and certainly before the capsule itself was recovered!  It was posted on LinkedIn by NASA’s Steve Yoon.  You can tell by the surface streaks on the heatshield,  that the stagnation point was toward the top left in this image,  but actually outside the view of the camera,  from when the image was taken. 

The basic heat shield surface in this photo looks quite intact,  so far as this image discloses!  Which means NASA was correct in saying that the change in entry trajectory from skip to non-skip reduced base heat shield damage!  There is no doubt about that!

You can see an inverted-U-shape mark on the heat shield,  which is located around where one of the hold-down pads was located.  You must look very close to see the other one visible in this view,  to image top right.  Yet,  it is there.  Neither of these is the whitish “stain” and erosion cavity that was seen in the CBS image and its zoom-in enhancement.  Those other two pad locations are not visible in this image’s view.  They are on the other side.

Figure III below is something I found posted on LinkedIn,  purported to be damage on the lateral capsule wall of Artemis-2,  but I do not believe that claim!  If this is even a photo of an Orion at all,  it has to be from the initial flight test EFT-1,  before the Artemis program began!  I say that because it is quite evident that there was a reinforcing hex in the pictured lateral heat shield!  There was such on EFT-1,  since it was built the same way as Apollo. There was no such reinforcing hex installed on either the Artemis-1 or Artemis-2 Orion capsules!  Those were insulated with cast and machined Avcoat tiles that had no reinforcing hex.

We are not going to see the real evidence,  until NASA actually releases photos of the entire base heat shield,  and photos of the lateral wall heat shield that include the attached flow side,  opposite where the windows and the hatch were located.  Such may not be forthcoming for some time.  But the laws (and ethics) require that such evidence actually be released to the public!

What I suspect,  but have zero evidence for,  is that the base heat shield still showed some chunk-shedding craters over on the stagnation-near-rim side,  just less than Artemis-1.  The enhanced CBS image does indicate that to be the case.  If that is true,  it says that NASA still needs to restore the reinforcing hex to the bonded Avcoat tiles that they want to use.

The other thing I suspect,  but still have zero evidence for,  is that increasing the heating by deleting the skip,  pushed one lateral side of the capsule into a situation of inadequate insulation thickness.  That would be the side away from the windows,  where attached flow might really happen.  This would be based upon the burn-throughs and total char losses seen in the enhanced CBS pre-splashdown image.  And perhaps that Figure III image,  or maybe not. 

We cannot know any better than my “informed speculations”,  until the full suite of “official” images might be released. 

Figure I – Photo of Reid Wiseman Pointing to Damage on Lateral Wall of Artemis-2 Capsule


Figure II – Navy Diver Photo of Artemis-2 Heat Shield in the Water,  via Steven Yoon, NASA


Figure III – LinkedIn Posting Photo,  of Lateral-Wall Heating Damage to a Space Capsule

-----  

 

Thursday, December 15, 2022

Fusion Still Unready To Save Us

Update 12-19-2022:  An edited version of this appeared in the Sunday 12-18-2022 Waco "Tribune-Herald" paper as a board-of-contributors column.  

---------------   

With scientists achieving “breakeven” at the national ignition facility,  their press release has been ballyhooed into notions that fusion is here to save us immediately from energy shortages and climate change.  Wrong!

Excerpted from an NBC News release 12-13-2022:

“While the Livermore team achieved what researchers call a scientific break-even or energy gain, it did not achieve an engineering break-even: The inefficient lasers used in the experiment required about 300 megajoules of energy to fire just 2 megajoules of energy into the experiment. The reaction produced about 3 megajoules of energy.”

and

“Scientists must now find ways to reduce inefficiencies, burn a larger portion of available fuel during the reaction and harness the energy for use as electricity, said Troy Carter, a professor in UCLA’s department of physics and astronomy and the director of the Plasma Science and Technology Institute.”

And here is an image of the target bay: 

My take on it:

Figured as output/input,  the scientists are comparing fusion energy released (as heat) to the incident laser light energy on the fuel pellet that compressed it:  3 megajoules/2 megajoules = 1.5,  which is greater than 1,  indicating they got more fusion-derived heat energy out,  than they put in as laser light energy (or magnetic confinement energy,  or whatever type of energy the experiment used). 

That definition of the ratio is termed “scientific breakeven”,  and this is the first time that ratio has ever exceeded 1 in anybody’s experiment!  That is quite the significant achievement!  However,  bear in mind that many experimenters have been trying to do that ever since the early 1950’s (some 7 decades ago).

That achievement says getting energy from fusion is actually theoretically possible.  But it ignores the efficiency of producing the input laser (or other) energy,  and it ignores the efficiency of utilizing the output heat to make usable electricity.  The second quoted paragraph above says exactly that,  but without any numbers to “calibrate” the notions.  Allow me to “calibrate” it for you:

Per the quoted data in the first quoted paragraph,  the efficiency of producing those 2 megajoules of laser energy is 2 megajoules/300 megajoules = 0.67%,  which is really,  really low! 

A heat engine is required to produce electricity from the released heat of fusion.  The best of those that we have,  are the steam-powered generators at power plants,  which are limited by the laws of thermodynamics to efficiencies in the range of 25-50%.  I will use that value range for illustration.

What all that really says,  from the viewpoint of any engineer actually tasked to build a powerplant,  is that the output should be the producible electricity,  say 25-50% x 3 megajoules,  or 0.75-1.5 megajoules.  The input is the energy required to actually produce the laser energy in this case,  which is the 300 megajoules quoted. 

Looked at that way,  the ratio is 0.75-1.5 megajoules/300 megajoules,  or about 0.25-0.50%,  and very likely lower than that.  And yet THAT is the ratio that really needs to be greater than 1 for a real-world powerplant design to work!  That would be “engineering breakeven”. 

It took 7 decades to achieve “scientific breakeven”.  It is unrealistic to expect that reaching “engineering breakeven” won’t require a similar number of decades.

*************************    

What we face:

We face a shortfall of grid capacity as the population increases and as motor fleet electrification proceeds,  plus we face a climate disaster already in progress.  For our energy and climate needs,  it is obviously wiser to count on techniques that we already have operational. Those are fossil fuels,  hydroelectric,  nuclear fission,  solar,  and wind.  Nothing else is operational.

How we can face it:

All the fossil fuels produce greenhouse gas emissions,  and the technologies to reduce or prevent that are simply not operational.  Of the fossil fuels,  the one cleanest of both ordinary pollution and greenhouse gas emissions is natural gas.  But you must pay careful attention to stopping the leaks from,  and the freezing of,  those pipelines and distribution infrastructure.  We know how to do that,  but we have yet to make those into regulatory requirements.  So,  change that lack!

Hydroelectric capacity cannot be expanded much further:  we have already dammed all the dammable rivers in the US.

Solar and wind are already 20+% of the Texas grid capacity,  but because of their intermittent nature and long-distance transmission losses,  they cannot be much more than that percentage,  until “grid-scale” energy storage is operational.  It is not yet operational.

That leaves nuclear fission,  which is free of conventional pollution and free of greenhouse emissions,  but does incur radioactive wastes and risks!  It has to be done “right”,  which prioritizes safety over profit,  which the US Navy has long-demonstrated really works.  It also needs a short-term and a long-term solution for dealing with the nuclear waste stream. 

The short-term nuclear waste solution is using the Yucca Mountain disposal facility already constructed in Nevada,  but so far never used.  Long-term,  we need to re-process spent nuclear fuel,  which might reduce the waste stream amounts,  by a factor approaching 10.

Just cut the red tape (while maintaining and enforcing the safety requirements) and get on with building nuclear plants as rapidly as we can!  We already know how.  No,  it’s not the cheapest source of electricity,  but it alone meets all the steady generation-capacity and emissions requirements.

My recommendations in a nutshell:



Thursday, October 21, 2021

Lists of Some Articles By Topic Area

Search code 21102021

-------   

Update 8-2-2026:     added multiple articles to multiple topics below. 

Update 2-10-2026:  added several to multiple topics below.

Update 6-10-2025:  added several to multiple topic areas below.

Update 4-10-2025:  added several to multiple categories below.

Update 4-7-2024:  added 3 to rocket,  below.

Update 3-6-2024:   added 3 to rocket,  below. 

Update 2-13-2024:  added 1 to ramjet and 6 to rocket, etc. below.

Update 10-1-2023:  added "Basic Thermal Results for High Speeds" to 2 topics below.

Update 9-2-2023:  added "Purported SR-72 Propulsion" to 3 topics below. 

Update 7-18-2023: added 1 article to forensics.  

Update 6-21-2023:  added 2 articles to rocket ballistics and vehicle performance list.

Update 5-4-2023: added 1 article each to aerothermo and forensics lists.

Update 2-4-23:  added new nozzles article to aerothermo and ballistics lists.

Update 1-1-23:  added catalog topic for towed decoys,  this text color.

Update 12-2-2022:  two ramjet articles added to that topic list,  this color.

Update 9-5-2022:  some recent articles added to the lists,  this text color.

Update 10-1-2022:  some others added,  this color.

Update 10-30-2022:  a couple added,  this color.

------------------------------

I was once an all-around ramjet design,  development,  and test engineer,  among many other things,  including rocket work.  This was mostly at a plant in McGregor,  Texas,  once known as Rocketdyne or Hercules.  Part of that reservation is where SpaceX tests rockets now. 

I did just about everything there was to do,  for this ramjet work.  There are very few indeed with knowledge and experience this comprehensive,  I was definitely not a narrow specialist!  But my knowledge and abilities,  in each of all these different specialty disciplines,  was actually quite substantial and deep!  

My design analyses usually took the form of custom hand-calculations,  not just sitting there blindly running other people’s computer codes.  (Although,  I did use computer codes,  and even wrote some myself.)  I have informally published several articles on my blog site that describe how some of this ramjet work was done.

Ramjet & Closely-Related Articles (there are others,  but these are the best):

9-1-2025:            On Pressure Vessels

6-1-2024:            Ramjet Ablative Liners

4-23-2024:          Presenter at Workshop (NC State U meeting on high temperature materials)

2-13-2024           GW's Ramjet Book Is Now Available 

10-1-2023            Basic Thermal Results for High Speeds

9-1-2023              Purported SR-72 Propulsion

12-2-2022            The Unchoked Gas Generator As A Throttle For Gas Generator-Fed Ramjets

12-1-2022            How Ramjets Work

10-30-22              Plasma Sheath Effects in High Hypersonic Flight

6-1-22                  About Hypersonic Vehicles

11-2-21                The “Warm Brick” Ramjet Device (nonpropulsive application to an infrared decoy)                                 [also the 11-2-21 update to this catalogue list]

10-1-21                Use of the Choked Pintle Valve for a Solid Propellant Gas Generator Throttle

8-2-21                  The Ramjet I Worked On the Most

7-1-21                  Another Ramjet I Worked On

11-9-20                Fundamentals of Inlets

3-3-20                  Ramjet Flameholding

2-16-20                Solid Rocket Analysis (applies to ramjet for boosters)

2-4-20                  One of Several Ramjets That I Worked On

1-2-20                  On High-Speed Aerodynamics and Heat Transfer

11-12-18              How Propulsion Nozzles Work

7-4-17                  Heat Protection Is the Key to Hypersonic Flight

6-12-17                Shock Impingement Heating Is Very Dangerous

12-10-16              Primer on Ramjets

12-21-12              Ramjet Cycle Analyses

These are located on http://exrocketman.blogspot.com,  along with many others on a wide variety of subjects. 

There is a navigation tool on the left of that page.  For the article you want,  you only need its publication date and its title.  Use the navigation tool:  click on the year,  then the month.  Then click on the title if you need to.  The data you need are in these lists.

If you click on one of the figures,  you can see all of them enlarged.  You see nothing but the figures,  though.  There is an “X-out” from this view,  upper right of screen.

At the end of any given article,  there is also a list of search keywords assigned to it.  If you click on “ramjet”,  you will only see the articles bearing that keyword.  The same is true of the other keywords.

Here follows a photo of one of the ramjets I worked on:  ASALM-PTV.  It is hanging under the wing of an A-7 Corsair-II,  an aircraft my father designed.  I always considered this photo a sort of “family portrait”. 

 

ASALM-PTV Ramjet Vehicle Underwing of A-7 Corsair-II

Some of those ramjet articles overlap with the next list.  That next list is of aerothermodynamics and heat transfer-related articles.  Some of these relate to high-speed atmospheric flight,  and others to atmospheric entry from space.  Those two scenarios are quite different,  in that atmospheric flight is a steady-state equilibrium problem,  while atmospheric entry is mostly a transient heat-sinking problem.  The search keyword for these is “aerothermo”.  Clearly,  I was adept at multiple specialties.

Aerothermodynamics & Heat Transfer Articles:

8-2-2026            What Nozzle Designs to Use Where, &Why

7-1-2026            Quick First Cut at Orion Entries (lunar)

6-1-2026            Entry Study (probes+Apollo, Earth & Mars)

5-1-2026            Entry By-Hand (how-to article)

4-28-2026          Preliminary Evaluation of Artemis-2 Heat Shield

3-01-2026          Ramjet Data Re: Heat Shields  

2-1-2026               Rocket Nozzles

11-2-2025             Get Acquainted Info: High Speed Vehicles

4-12-2025             Ballistic Coefficient Study for Earth Entry

7-2-2024               Recent Heat Protection Items, 3 of 3

6-1-2024               Ramjet Ablative Liners

5-23-2024:            Entry Concept Screening

4-23-2024:            Presenter at Workshop (NC State U meeting on high temperature materials)

1-2-2024              Airplanes on Mars?

12-9-2023            Overall Study Results:  Propellant From Moon

11-22-2023          How the Suborbital "Hopper" Calculations Were Made and With What

11-21-2023          Upgraded Rocket Hopper As Orbit Taxi

11-4-2023            Surface Freight Transport On Mars (not actually rocket,  but related)

11-1-2023            Rocket Hopper For Mars Planetary Transportation

10-1-2023            Basic Thermal Results for High Speeds

9-1-2023              Purported SR-72 Propulsion

5-1-23                  Heat Shields

2-4-23                  Rocket Nozzle Types (bells and aerospikes)

9-18-22                Plasma Sheath Effects in Hypersonic Flight

7-3-22                  Early High-Speed Experimental Planes

6-1-22                  About Hypersonic Vehicles

4-1-20                  Entry Heating Estimates

1-2-20                  On High-Speed Aerodynamics and Heat Transfer

1-9-19                  Subsonic Inlet Duct Investigation

1-6-19                  A Look At Nosetips (Or Leading Edges)

1-2-19                  Thermal Protection Trends For High-Speed Atmospheric Flight

11-12-18              How Propulsion Nozzles Work

7-4-17                  Heat Protection Is the Key to Hypersonic Flight

6-12-17                Shock Impingement Heating Is Very Dangerous

11-17-15              Why Air Is Hot When You Fly Fast

8-4-13                  Entry Issues

3-18-13                Low-Density Non-Ablative Ceramic Heat Shields

1-21-13                BOE Entry Analysis of Apollo Returning From the Moon

1-21-13                BOE Entry Model User’s Guide

8-19-12                Ballute Drag Data

8-19-12                Blunt Capsule Drag Data

7-14-12                “Back Of the Envelope” Entry Model

I was also a rocket propulsion engineer,  mostly in solid composite propellants.  However,  from the chamber outlet through the nozzle,  the ballistics of all rockets are the same,  including liquid propellant rockets.  If you can allow for any gas bled off and dumped overboard for turbopump operation,  then the very same ballistics apply,  right down to the chamber pressure vs flow rate calculation. 

Further,  the estimation of vehicle performance from the simple rocket equation can be made quite accurate,  if you know how to apply “jigger factors” in the appropriate places for gravity and drag losses,  and if you know what values of these “jigger factors” to apply.  I have been very successful at doing this kind of work. The following list shows that,  and mostly shares the “launch” and “space program” keywords.  While still a graduate student,  I spent a summer doing advanced configuration and mission work at what was then LTV Aerospace,  working on its "Scout" 4-stage solid satellite launcher. 

Rocket Ballistics and Rocket Vehicle Performance articles:

8-2-2026          What Nozzle Designs to Use Where, &Why

7-26-2026        Kudos to SpaceX for Flight 13

7-1-2026           Quick First Cut at Orion Entries (lunar)

6-1-2026           Entry Study (probes+Apollo, Earth & Mars)

5-27-2026         Kudos to SpaceX for Flight 12 

5-19-2026         Launch to Low Orbit Study (SSTO, TSTO)

5-18-2026         Launch Vehicle Rough-Out (SSTO, TSTO)

4-28-2026         Preliminary Evaluation of Artemis-2 Heat Shield

4-14-2026         Elliptic Departure and Arrival

2-21-2026         Space-Based AI?  Not Easy!

2-1-2026              Rocket Nozzles

1-1-2026              Landing Pads for Rocket Vehicles

12-1-2025            Criteria for Rough-Field Landings

11-11-2025          Where Should the New Space Stations Be Located?

10-16-2025          Going Back to the Moon

9-1-2025              On Pressure Vessels

8-1-2025               Air Launch to Low Earth Orbit

7-26-2025             Tank Design for Easy Cryogenic Transfers in Weightlessness

6-23-2025:            Starship Explosion (forensics)

6-1-2025               SpaceX “Starship” Flight Test 9 

5-1-2025              Vehicle Assembly and Refueling Facility in LEO

4-1-2025              About Nuclear Pulse Propulsion

3-13-2025            Rough/Soft Field Space Landings

3-7-2025              Upper-Stage Starship Failure,  Test 8

3-2-2025              Spin Gravity

2-21-2025            Asteroid 2024YR4 Threat

2-9-2025              There Is Nothing As Expensive As a Dead Crew

2-1-2025              Exploring Mars Is Not Settling Mars

1-25-2025            Initial Study for Tug Missions LEO to LLO

1-2-2025              SpaceX's Starship As a Space Tug (update looks at Centaur)

12-1-2024            Tug-Assisted Arrivals and Departures

11-1-2024            Getting to Low Earth Orbit and Back

10-13-2024          Starship/Superheavy Flt. Test 5,  13 Oct '24

10-1-2024            Elliptic Capture

9-13-2024            What Went Wrong? (problems with Starliner and at Boeing in general )

9-1-2024              Rocket Equation-Based Launch Vehicle Analyses

7-2-2024              Recent Heat Protection Items, 3 of 3

5-3-2024              Entry Concept Screening

4-23-2024            Presenter at Workshop (NC State U meeting on high temperature materials)

4-4-2024              Ascent Compromise Design Trade Study

4-3-2024              Bounding Analyses for TSTO

4-2-2024              Bounding Calculations for SSTO Concepts 

2-25-2024            Tricky Landing

3-3-2024              Launch to Low Earth Orbit:  1 or 2 Stages?

3-4-2024              Launch to Low Earth Orbit:  Fixed Geometry Options

9-1-2023              Purported SR-72 Propulsion

6-20-23                TSTO Launch Fundamentals

6-6-23                  Frontal Thrust Density In Rockets

2-4-23                  Rocket Nozzle Types (bells and aerospikes)

10-27-22              Getting to Low Earth Orbit  (vertical ballistic launch versus lifting ascent)

10-1-22                Rocket Engine Calculations (how to rough-out or reverse-engineer, ex: Raptor-2)

9-7-22                  Two-Stage Reusable Spaceplane Rough-Size (VTO HL both stages)

8-4-22                  Engineering Lander/Rover for Mars

5-1-22                  Investigation:  "Big Ship" Propellant From the Moon vs From Earth (added to list as part of Update 5-1-22)

4-2-22                  Earth-Mars Orbit-to-Orbit Transport Propulsion Studies (added to list as part of Update 5-1-22) 

2-1-22                  A Concept for an On-Orbit Propellant Depot

8-18-21                Propellant Ullage Problem and Solutions

3-15-21                Reverse Engineering Estimates: Starship Lunar Landings

3-9-21                  Reverse-Engineering Starship/Superheavy 2021

3-5-21                  Fundamentals of Elliptic Orbits (delta-vee requirements)

2-9-21                  Rocket Vehicle Performance Spreadsheet (rocket vehicle performance)

7-13-20                Non-Direct to the Moon with 2020 Starship

7-5-20                  How the Spreadsheet Works (Starship to Mars)

7-5-20                  2020 Starship/Superheavy Estimates for the Moon

7-3-20                  Cis-Lunar Orbits and Requirements

6-21-20                2020 Starship/Superheavy Estimates for Mars

5-25-20                2020 Reverse Engineering Estimates for Starship/Superheavy

2-16-20                Solid Rocket Analysis (solid ballistics & more)

11-21-19              Interplanetary Trajectories and Requirements

10-22-19              Reverse-Engineering the 2019 Version of The Spacex “Starship” / “Super Heavy” Design

9-26-19                Reverse-Engineered “Raptor” Engine Performance (liquid ballistics)

9-16-19                Spacex “Starship” as a Ferry for Colonization Ships

9-9-19                  Colonization Ship Study

11-12-18              How Propulsion Nozzles Work (rocket, ramjet, & turbine; plain & free-expansion)

9-11-18                Velocity Requirements for Mars

8-23-18                Back-of-the-Envelope Rocket Propulsion Analysis (rocket vehicle performance)

4-17-18                Reverse Engineering the 2017 Version of the Spacex BFR

10-23-17              Reverse-Engineering the ITS/Second Stage Of the Spacex BFR/ITS System

3-18-17                Bounding Analysis for Lunar Lander Designs (rocket vehicle performance)

3-6-17                  Reverse-Engineered “Dragon” Data (rocket vehicle performance)

8-31-13                Reusable Chemical Mars Landing Boats Are Feasible (rocket vehicle performance)

In 2009,  I attended an asteroid defense conference in Granada,  Spain,  as a poster paper presenter.  I have since written some articles about asteroid defense.  Unfortunately,  the asteroid defense capability picture hasn’t changed much since my 2009 attendance at that conference.  Again,  the latest are the best and most up-to-date.   Be aware that “NEO” (Near Earth Object) includes comets as well as asteroids as threats.  Comets may be the more difficult to defend against,  because of the surprise nature of the detection and orbits.  These articles all share the “asteroid defense” keyword.

Asteroid Defense Articles:

5-8-2025               Re-Entering Space Junk Threats

2-21-2025            Asteroid 2024YR4 Threat

8-30-20                Asteroid Threats  (current status assessment:  not good)

6-3-20                  On the Manned Spacex Launch

7-14-19                Just Mooning Around (asteroids plus Mars)

12-13-13              Mars Mission Study 2013 (what takes you to Mars takes you to asteroids)

4-21-09                On Asteroid Defense and a Good Reason for Having National Space Programs

I have also applied my wide-ranging knowledge to the problems of atmospheres to breathe while in space,  and the kinds of spacesuits that might best serve our needs.  Again,  the latest is the best and most up-to-date.  But I have been looking into these issues for some time,  as indicated by the dates on these articles.  These all share the “spacesuit” keyword.

Space Suits and Atmospheres Articles:

7-8-2025              Oxygenation Issues for Habitats and Space Suits

1-2-22                  Refining Proposed Suit and Habitat Atmospheres (update 1-2-22) best case and easiest-to-remember cases,  plus an independent estimate of the utter min suit pressures feasible

1-1-22                  Habitat Atmospheres and Long-Term Health (update 1-1-22)  adds a long term hypoxia criterion for the habitat in addition to short term criteria for the min-P suit

3-16-18                Suit and Habitat Atmospheres 2018

11-23-17              A Better Version of the MCP Spacesuit?

2-15-16                Suits and Atmospheres for Space

1-15-16                Astronaut Facing Drowning Points Out Need for Better Space Suit

11-17-14              Space Suit and Habitat Atmospheres

2-11-14                On-Orbit Repair and Assembly Facility

12-13-13              Mars Mission Study 2013

1-21-11                Fundamental Design Criteria for Alternative Space Suit Approaches

One of my favorites is the MCP (mechanical counter pressure) version of the spacesuit.  This was pioneered by Dr. Webb in the 1960’s as a possible suit for the Apollo missions to the moon.  It is not a full pressure suit at all,  but essentially a tight garment that simply squeezes the body.  It is porous,  so that you sweat right through it to cool,  just like ordinary street clothing.  But this design was tested quite successfully in 1968 for 30 minutes in a vacuum chamber,  at way above the equivalent “vacuum deathpoint” altitude.  Photo follows:


Webb’s MCP Space Suit:  Helmet,  Backpack,  and Supple Garment Total 85 Lbs

The reason why I like this approach over Dava Newman's designs is that Webb's designs are essentially vacuum-protective underwear that can be easily laundered.  Over them you wear whatever unpressurized clothing you need for protection from from heat,  cold,  and mechanical hazards.  All of these are separate,  easily laundered items.  I think the "one garment that does everything" approach,  that we have been using since about 1960,  is wrong.  "Mix and match" is way more flexible.

Besides vacuum death and microgravity disease,  there is also a radiation hazard to worry about in space.  But,  it is not quite what you think:  there are two completely different hazards to worry about.  On Earth,  we have two kinds of protection:  the atmosphere,  and the magnetic field.  In low Earth orbit,  we have only the magnetic field.  Outside the magnetic field,  going to the moon or anywhere else,  there is no protection.  Yet these things can be quantified,  and some of it shielded fairly effectively.  What got me started on this topic were the dangers posed by the nuclear disaster in Fukushima,  Japan.  Keyword “radiation”.

NASA has since lowered its career exposure limits below the older values I had obtained from them.  That avoids the slight chance of cancer late in life due to galactic cosmic ray exposure over long times in space.  But,  it makes passive shielding design bulkier,  heavier,  and more difficult to design.  It's really a trade-off.  However,  NASA still has not faced up to the erratic but intense floods of radiation from solar eruptions.  They haven't yet killed a crew from this,  although they came close to that during Apollo.  But if they don't address this,  they will kill a crew,  once we move out beyond the Van Allen belts,  and try to stay there.  That includes the return to the moon.  

Radiation Hazard Articles:

10-5-18                Space Radiation Risks:  GCR vs SFE

4-11-15                Radiation Risks for Mars Trip

5-2-12                  Space Travel Radiation Risks

3-24-11                Radiation and Humans

3-17-11                Follow-Up On the Japan Nuclear Crisis

3-15-11                On the Nuclear Crisis In Japan

On a lighter note,  I have long been interested in pulsejet engines,  especially valveless pulsejets.  While teaching math at TSTC,  Waco,  I became involved with mentoring a student who was also interested in pulsejets.  I and a colleague assisted this student in making his own valveless pulsejet engines,  which attention and involvement also turned this student into an “A” student in math!  Keyword “pulsejet”.

That student built a small engine that eventually pushed an old golf cart around,  and then a much bigger engine which we together fired up out here on my farm homestead.  Photos of the two engines follow:

Smaller Student-Built Valveless Pulsejet Engine (Later Pushed a Golf Cart)


Larger Student-Built Valveless Pulsejet Engine

Pulsejet Articles:

5-20-12                Recommended Broad Design Guidelines For Valveless Pulsejet Combustors

4-30-12                Big Student Pulsejet an Even Larger Hit at TSTC

3-6-12                  Student Pulsejet a Hit at EAA Meeting

11-12-11              Student Pulsejet Project

I have been interested in ethanol fuels since my early days in college.  When I went to work for what is now Minnesota State University,  after my 20-year career in aerospace defense work ended,  I got more serious about it.  My next job was at Baylor University in Waco,  Texas,  and it dealt directly in alternative fuels for aircraft.  The scope of that included ethanol (and an ether) as piston-engine fuels,  and biodiesel-jet fuel blends as turbine fuels,  plus STC work with the FAA,  and also experimental engineering research work,  as well as classroom teaching. 

Not too long after leaving Baylor,  I began my own experimental engineering research at home,  using E-85 ethanol fuel,  and stiff ethanol blends,  in a variety of vehicles.  Those would include straight E-85 ethanol fuel in an old farm tractor and in an old-time air-cooled VW beetle,  plus stiff ethanol blends in a variety of completely-unmodified cars and 4-stroke lawn and garden equipment.  I basically recommend up to E-35 blend strength,  as a “drop-in” fuel,  for just about any 4-stroke piston engine. 

The keywords are “ethanol” and “old cars” for most of these articles.  Once again,  the latest is the best and most up-to-date.

Articles About Ethanol and Ethanol Blends in Vehicles:

9-1-21                  Making Stiff Blends At the Gas Pump

11-3-13                Aviation Alternative Fuel Compatibility Issues

11-2-13                An Update on Ethanol Fuel Use

8-9-12                  Biofuels in General and Ethanol in Particular

5-4-12                  Energy Storage: Batteries vs Unpressurized Liquid Fuels

6-12-11                Another Red-Letter Day

5-5-11                  Ethanol Does Not Hurt Engines

2-12-11                “How-To” For Ethanol and Blend Vehicles

11-17-10              Nissan Mileage Results on Blends

11-12-10              Stiff Blend Effects in Gasoline Cars

12-15-09              Red Letter Day:  Ethanol VW Experiment Complete

7-1-09                  Another Antique Comes Out of Storage

I have returned part-time out of retirement to help a friend with his auto repair business.  I was once ASE-certified as a condition of employment while teaching at Minnesota State in its Automotive and Manufacturing Engineering Technology department.  Before that,  I did most of my own automotive maintenance and repair work.  Accordingly,  I have posted some articles about basic car care,  plus one funny.  These all share the “old cars” and “fun stuff” keywords. 

I have since gone back into retirement.  My friend now has a real mechanic,  who knows more than I do,  and is much more experienced,  and faster. 

Automotive Care Articles:

8-22-22                Automotive Work (another "funny")

3-4-22                  Understanding Your Tires (added to this list as update 5-1-22)

12-3-20                Blinker Fluid (the “funny”,  and it is a sight gag)

8-20-20                Underhood Check

7-25-20                Taking Care of Car Batteries

When I returned to the rocket plant in McGregor for my second employment there,  the family and I acquired an old farm outside McGregor as our home.  We have been there ever since.  This place was largely covered in shin- to knee-high prickly pear cactus,  so thick there were few trails through it.  After grubbing it out of the house’s back yard with hand tools,  I decided there had to be a better way to do this cactus eradication. 

I tried a variety of mechanical drags behind my old farm tractor for some 15 years without success.  The results were always the same:  it looked better for a while,  but returned worse than ever before,  within months.  My neighbor was trying shredding at 1 inch off the ground.  Eventually that worked,  but required the neighbor to be out there shredding,  every single day,  the same ground over and over,  for 6 (or more) years.  The neighbor also tried spraying herbicides on one patch of ground,  which took 3 years to show results,  but then totally reinfested within another 2 years.

I then tried to build a “scooper-upper” out of scrap steel.  The idea was to bust the aboveground cactus loose from its roots,  and catch it on a tarp towed behind the “scoop-upper”,  for disposal in a burn pit.  It completely failed to work,  because when the tool hit the cactus and busted it loose from its roots,  it fell forward in front of the tool,  instead of backward onto the deck.  The tool then just ran over the top of the cactus debris.  I gave up in disgust when this failure-to-scoop happened.

I went back up a few months later to salvage the steel,  and saw something totally unexpected:  the cactus was dead and gone wherever the tool had been towed!  Grass was growing in the cow pasture where the cactus had been.  It did not take very long to understand that the aboveground cactus foliage had been crushed and damaged passing underneath the heavy tool,  such that the pads dried out and died,  before they could put down new roots from the thorn sites in contact with soil.  They had completely composted away over those months.

I “played” with this tool to get it just “right”,  and started killing acres of prickly pear quite effectively,  and with very little time and effort involved.  In fact,  I still have this very same experimental prototype,  and it still works today.  This prototype led to me filing a patent on the cactus tool in 2002. 

I revised the design to something more producible from real steel stocks,  and built two production prototypes that worked just as well as the original experimental prototype,  but were easier to build.  Then,  with the patent in hand as of 2004,  I began building and selling these tools to the public.  My first customer wouldn’t wait for a real production tool,  and insisted on buying one of the two production prototypes.  I still have the other one.  I still use it,  and it now serves as an experimental test bed for new features,  too.

As time went by,  it quickly became apparent that other folks had rockier land,  or land with tree stumps.  I changed the design twice,  to add a heavier stabilizing snout,  plus a “barge front” wedging surface to get over small rock outcrops.  This was quite successful,  and is embodied in the tools still built and sold today.

A close friend wanted to do cactus-killing for hire,  and bought a “one-off” design from me.  I also helped him build and modify a few more tools,  until the “commercial version” was defined:  a really tough snout,  a big “barge front”,  and retractable wheels to facilitate stepping over obstacles,  plus easier loading up ramps onto trailers. 

When that friend retired,  I revised his “commercial” design into something that used a common core tool chassis with my “homeowner grade” plain tool.  This common core chassis had the big barge front,  and used either a tough snout for the “plain tool”,  or a longer tough snout for the “hydraulic tool”,  that was also fitted with retractable wheels operated hydraulically.  I sell both versions to this very day.  Both are towed on a chain bridle behind a farm tractor’s drawbar.

I am working on a third version that could be an alternative implement affixed to the hydraulic boom of a skid-steer loader.  It uses an already-available “universal” adapter plate to accomplish this,  as a quick-change item.  There is nothing to report here yet about that project,  but the “plain” and “hydraulic” tools are well-described in a series of articles on “exrocketman” under the keyword “cactus-killing”. 

These two versions are shown in the photo,  with the plain tool in the foreground,  and the hydraulic tool in the background.

Foreground:  Plain Tool;  Background:  Hydraulic (Wheeled) Tool

The new skid-steer version has been tested and revised to a form that not only works,  but is more easily manufacturable.  It is now patent pending. 

Articles Related to Cactus Eradication:

2-9-17                  Time Lapse Proof It Works

7-30-15                New Cactus Tool Website

1-8-15                  Kactus Kicker Development

1-8-14                  Kactus Kicker:  Recent Progress

10-12-13              Construction of the Plain Cactus Tool

5-19-13                Loading Steel Safely (Cactus Tool)

12-19-12              Using the Cactus Tool or Tools

11-1-12                About the Kactus Kicker

12-28-11              Latest Production Version of the Kactus Kicker

 Update 12-1-2021:  these articles are more-or-less forensic analyses of various events:

7-26-2026          Kudos to SpaceX for Flight 13

6-9-2026            Close Call at Newark

5-27-2026          Kudos to SpaceX for Flight 12

6-23-2025            Starship Explosion (forensics)

6-1-2025               SpaceX “Starship” Flight Test 9

3-13-2025            Rough/Soft-Field Space Landings

3-7-2025              Upper-Stage Starship Failure,  Test 8

2-9-2025              There Is Nothing As Expensive As a Dead Crew

10-13-2024          Starship/Superheavy Flight Test 5,  13 Oct 2024

9-13-2024            What Went Wrong?  (problems with Starliner and at Boeing)

7-7-23                  On the loss of the "Titan" Submersible  (added 7-18-23)

4-25-23                Starship/Superheavy Flight Test

12-1-21                The Seal Failure in the SRB That Doomed Challenger

12-10-20              Spacex Test Flight Results in Explosion

9-1-20                  On the Beirut Explosion

5-4-18                  Some Thoughts on the Anniversary of the West Explosion

11-1-14                Two Commercial Spaceflight Disasters in One Week

7-9-13                  On the Asiana 214 Crash

7-9-13                  On the Train Wreck in Quebec

4-18-13                Fertilizer Explosion in West,  Texas

9-23-11                Air Races,  Air Shows,  and Risks

6-3-10                  Plenty of Blame to Go Around for the Disaster in the Gulf

5-20-10                It really was the North Koreans who sank the South Korean ship

Update 1-1-23:  these are the articles related to towed decoys:

Between my tenures at the McGregor rocket shop,  I worked at what was then Tracor Aerospace in Austin,  Texas,  doing aircraft and ICBM countermeasures work.  The bulk of this related to towed aircraft decoys,  which are more advanced aircraft countermeasures against missiles than the traditional chaff and flares.  I did all sorts of lab,  wind tunnel,  and flight tests with these things.  To a great extent,  I had to design my own tests,  test hardware,  and equipment,  too. 

Tracor Austin became part of British Aerospace after I left to go back to the rocket shop in McGregor,  and it closed entirely,  only somewhat later.  When you combine the typical corporate management misbehavior with the massive defense industry contraction that happened after the fall of the Soviet Union,  this plant closure outcome is entirely unsurprising.  That was as true for the rocket shop as well as for Tracor.  And it is why I had to leave the aerospace defense industry entirely,  after being laid off in late 1994 due to the rocket plant closure in McGregor.

My work at Tracor in towed aircraft decoys related to two distinct types of decoys:  towed hard body decoys,  and towed ribbons.  The hard bodies are exactly that:  some sort of small airframe towed behind the aircraft that it is intended to protect,  on some sort of towline.  These could be radar (RF) decoys to replace chaff,  or they could be infrared (IR) decoys to replace flares and jammers.  I worked on both of these towed decoy types (RF and IR).  Towed RF decoys are now operational with the air forces of multiple nations,  because they really work.

The towed ribbon decoys are quite different,  being rather similar to windsocks and soft towed gunnery targets.  The technologies supporting this concept apply only to RF,  and are restricted to only extreme-low observables aircraft.  I also worked on these.  One huge issue is stable tow for extended periods of time,  when the “flapping-flag” effect wants to destroy them in mere seconds at jet aircraft speeds. 

Obviously,  deployment,  especially very rapid deployment,  is another huge issue with these ribbon decoys,  as well as with the hard body decoys. Solving it requires expertise in dynamics as well as aerodynamics,  plus knowledge of all sorts of mechanisms. 

Here is the list of my towed decoy articles available as of this update.  Future updates may add more. 

1-1-23                  Towed Hardbody Decoys  (could IR or RF)

11-2-21                The “Warm Brick” Ramjet Device (nonpropulsive application to an infrared decoy)   

Later                     possible articles on deployment and on towed ribbons